top of page

Part 1: Before You Trust the Damages Number, Test the Earnings Baseline

Writer: John E Beauzile
John E Beauzile
10 minutes ago
1 min read

The damages figure gets the attention. The earnings baseline deserves the scrutiny. In a personal injury, wrongful death, or wrongful termination case, even a polished report can rest on a shaky starting number. Before you debate decades of projected losses, ask a simpler question. What supports the income figure in year one?


The Red Flag: A Starting Number Without Support. One unusually strong tax year. Income reported by the claimant but never verified. A wage figure that does not match payroll records or employment history. Each is a reason to dig deeper; not to assume the baseline is sound.


Why Trial Counsel Should Care. Wage growth, fringe benefits, and present-value calculations all build on the baseline. An unsupported increase at the outset carries through the model. The issue is not just whether the first number looks plausible; it is whether the records explain why that number belongs in the calculation.


Put The Issue to Work in Discovery


For Defense Counsel: Request complete W-2 records, multi-year tax returns, and payroll records. Compare the selected year with the surrounding years and ask the expert to explain any departure from the earnings history.


For Plaintiff's Counsel: Give the expert the records needed to defend the starting figure. If a higher-earning year reflect a permanent promotion rather than on-time overtime, document that distinction before the deposition.


The Takeaway: Start with the inputs, not the headline number. A baseline tied to the records gives you a firmer footing for settlement discussions and expert examination. If you need an objective evaluation of an economic report, feel free to contact us.




Comments


bottom of page